The Dirty Secret of Zoos and Why Animals Are Fat
Zoos have a dirty secret: many of the animals are fat. And obesity is the least of it: cavities and lethargy are common; some species even have heart disease and Type II Diabetes. You won’t hear this embarrassing fact on a guided tour, and you won’t read it on any tour signs. What you will see are signs that say: DO NOT FEED THE ANIMALS.
The primary purpose of these signs is to prevent people from giving hot dog buns, popcorn, and peanuts to the captive animals. But the signs teach another important point: it can be beneficial to not feed the animals. Animals benefit from going hungry sometimes. Fasting can be healthy.
Consider the lion. Wild lions often go days without eating. Not feeding is a normal and natural part of their life. But after a kill – perhaps a juicy antelope – lions will gorge on the carcass. Lions alternate being fasting and feasting. It’s what lions are designed to do.
Yet in too many zoos, captive lions are fed on a regular daily schedule. Zoos ignore their own advice: DO NOT FEED THE ANIMALS. When one zoo decided to switch lions back to a gorge-and-fast feeding schedule, something incredible happened:
In 1993 the Topeka Zoo had five overweight lions. They were fed on a regular schedule (once a day, six days a week), but the zoo decided to switch to a “gorge and fast” feeding schedule (once a day, three days a week) modeled after wild lions, which typically eat every two to three days. The food was kept the same—a ground mixture containing horsemeat—and each lion received the same amount of food over the course of a week as it had before; they now received larger portions on feeding days. The lions were allowed to eat until they had their fill and walked away from their food. Only then were leftovers removed from the enclosure. The four weekly fasting days were chosen at random, which meant that the lions sometimes experienced four days in a row of fasting.
Previously, the lions had always finished their meals, but now four of the five routinely left portions of their meal uneaten. The result was a decrease in weekly overall caloric intake—and significant weight loss. Four of the five lions lost from 9 to 16% of their total body weight (the fifth lion injured her leg and had been under veterinary care leading up to the measuring period). However, the benefits weren’t simply due to eating fewer calories; based on fecal samples, the lions digested their food more thoroughly and efficiently under the gorge and fast model.
Both captive gorillas and lions suffered from the same issue: we forced them to accommodate our regimented workdays. They were being fed on a human schedule, not a schedule based on how their species naturally eats in the wild.
So what’s a natural eating frequency for humans?
Too many nutritionists get it exactly wrong – advising people to eat lots of small snacks throughout the day in order to “keep their blood sugar up.” It’s called grazing for a reason – grazing is how herbivores eat, not carnivores or omnivores.
Humans can benefit from the same approach that helped the lions lose weight. Fasting and feasting can make it easier to lose weight.
Aaron V says
I’ve been fasting and feasting for a while now ( I average 1-2 meals a day) ,it’ll be nice to hear more about this particular way of eating.
Emily Dewey says
Hope you enjoyed it Aaron! – Emily, FBM Team
Interesting perspective! Love the concept of equating human and animal eating patterns.
Emily Dewey says
Pretty cool stuff isn’t is Sylvie? 😉 – Emily, FBM Team
ur pretty cool Emily Dewey ..
Just listening to the interview on paleocon… I was wondering if fasting and feasting is okay when being pregnant. I’m just over 4 weeks pregnant and I noticed that I’m not hungry at all. Preferably wanting to skip lunches… Eating makes me nauseous.
When I eat, it’s healthy… Paleo.
Love to hear from you.
Emily Dewey says
Hi Chantal – we can’t provide that kind of medical advice for liability purposes I’m afraid… Congratulations on your baby though, how exciting! 🙂 – Emily, FBM Team
Agreed! Please provide more information about feasting and fasting. Interesting topic and I am definitely interested in learning more about it. Thank you.
I have been practicing IF for some time now, and love it. I’m wondering, though, what to consider when trying to add muscle mass (not bodybuilder type, just increasing size and strength). Is it possible to get the calories and protein necessary?
Fasting is really a very best technique to lose weight. But we have to do fasting in a disciplined way to achieve quick weight loss.
Emily Dewey says
Disciplined yes, but also safe. It’s important to still have regard for your body’s cues and respond accordingly! – Emily, FBM Team
Hyok Lee says
I’ve done intermittent fasting, and it is something I still employ on occasion. But, I don’t like the cold hands I get during the fast. I would rather count macros. I know, I know, it’s not “wild” or “natural,” I like the freedom of eating when I want, as long as I hit my daily totals.
Abel James says
Awesome Hyok – keep doing what works best for you!
how long to you fast for?
I really wish they would give more of an explanation on fasting, Such as a menu plan for fasting and eating like he semi did on the show. I just bought this package and son far feel its a waste of my money. I don’t have a printer to print the stuff out and I only have an Ipad that does not have alot of memory to be downloading everything. You have to pay extra (which I don’t have) to be able to be a TEAM player. At this point I just don’t know if I’m going to cancel or not. Cant even find the car snack pack that he had Kurt make in the show.
The only thing that is different though ( and it is a BIG difference ) is the food carnivores eat compared to humans. If we had to feast on lean meat, it would be difficult to do so beyond a point and that could result in muscle deficit.
Moreover I am not sure our digestive system is equipped to handling the overeating. But that is something it can be trained over time.
Just my two cents to this interesting theory.
Trim Contour says
This is very much great and hope fully nice blog. Every body can easily get perfect information from here.Thanks for sharing your post and keep updating us with such great post.